|
Go
to page-4 You are on Page-3
go to page-2
Go to page -1 Journal of
Neurology Neurosurgery and Psychiatry
2003;74:ii9
© 2003
MANAGEMENT OF INFLAMMATORY NEUROPATHIES
Robert D M Hadden1 and
Richard A C Hughes2
|
|
CHRONIC
INFLAMMATORY DEMYELINATING POLYRADICULONEUROPATHY (CIDP)
|
Clinical
presentation
The time course of CIDP may be relapsing–remitting, chronic
progressive, monophasic or have a GBS-like onset. Motor and
sensory nerves are usually involved. Several variants are now
being recognised (box 3 ).
Most of the inflammation occurs in the proximal roots.
Symptoms are primarily caused by conduction block
resulting from demyelination, which generally responds
well to treatment. The degree of block of conduction may also
be increased by physical factors such as temperature, ischaemia,
and exercise, which can explain rapid fluctuations in
symptoms. After some years of disease there is a gradual
accumulation of axonal degeneration, clinically evident
as wasted muscles, which is generally irreversible. In
the later stages disability is caused by a combination of
axonal degeneration and demyelination, and responsiveness
to treatment gradually decreases. Half of all patients
suffer temporary severe disability and 13% have a long
term requirement for aids to walk. Factors associated
with a better prognosis are younger age, relapsing–remitting
course, and absence of axonal damage.
|
|
|
|
|
Box 3 Variants of chronic
inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy
- Symmetrical sensory and
motor CIDP
- Sensory CIDP
- Motor CIDP
- Multifocal acquired
demyelinating sensory and motor (MADSAM) neuropathy
- Multifocal motor
neuropathy
|
Diagnosis and investigation
The diagnosis is made on the basis of nerve conduction studies.
Conduction slowing and prolonged distal motor latencies occur
in both CIDP and hereditary demyelinating neuropathy, but CIDP
is distinguished by the presence of motor conduction block,
temporal dispersion, and asymmetric involvement, indicating
a multifocal process. F-responses are delayed and often
absent. Such abnormalities should be present in at least
three nerves to meet diagnostic criteria. Some nerves may
appear to be normal or to have axonal neurophysiology, so
the diagnosis may be missed if too few nerves are tested
and proximal conduction block is not specifically sought.
A nerve biopsy is sometimes diagnostic, but not necessary
and now not routinely done. Most patients with CIDP have
axonal degeneration without demyelination on sural nerve
biopsy. Serum protein electrophoresis should be done
initially and annually thereafter, because the development
of a paraprotein may indicate an alternative diagnosis and
treatment (see later). Measurement of serum
autoantibodies is not usually helpful. The CSF protein is
raised in at least 80% of patients. A minority of
patients has evidence of coexistent asymptomatic CNS
demyelination on magnetic resonance imaging or evoked potential
examination.
Immune modulating treatment
Corticosteroids were the first accepted treatment but entered
clinical practice without today’s high standards of evidence.
Corticosteroids induce at least short term improvement in
65–95% of patients (level 1a and 4 evidence). There are
many regimens. We prefer oral prednisolone 1.5 mg/kg on
alternate days in a single morning dose with careful
review and dose adjustment at two weekly intervals for 12
weeks, when a judgement needs to be made about whether to
continue or switch to IVIg. Improvement begins after 1–4
weeks (but occasionally months), and reaches a plateau at
about six months. Occasional patients deteriorate on
steroids by an unknown mechanism, especially those with pure
motor forms of CIDP or with multifocal motor neuropathy with
conduction block. Prednisolone is cheap but has serious long
term adverse effects. Osteoporosis prophylaxis should be
started at the same time.
Plasma exchange was efficacious in two sham controlled randomised
trials (level 1b evidence). One trial used PE twice weekly for
three weeks, and the other used four exchanges in the first
week, three in the second, two in the third, and one in the
fourth. To maintain improvement PE has to be repeated at
intervals as short as four weeks. Its usefulness is
limited by its inconvenience, venous access problems,
requirement for hospital attendance and specially trained
staff, and adverse events. Complications, usually from
the use of a central venous catheter, were reported in
one series in 17% of 381 procedures and one was fatal.
IVIg appeared efficacious in three of four randomised trials
and the efficacy was supported by a meta-analysis
border=0 width=8 height=7 src="polyneuropathy_37_files/image001.gif" title=""
v:shapes="_x0000_s1027">
,
level 1a evidence).9
Unfortunately its benefit lasts only 2–12 weeks, so that
treatment has to be repeated and is very expensive.
Approximately two thirds of patients respond, of whom one third
improve and need no further treatment and two thirds require
repeated courses. The initial dose should be 0.4 g/kg daily
for five days (smaller doses were less effective), but
maintenance doses can usually be reduced to 0.4–2.0 g/kg
in total and given over 1–2 days. Crossover trials have
shown no significant short term difference between IVIg
and PE (courses of similar cost) or between IVIg and oral
prednisolone.
|
|
Figure 3 Chronic
inflammatory demyelinating
polyradiculoneuropathy. Relative rate of
improvement 2–6 weeks after randomisation to
intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) or placebo.
Reproduced from van Schaik et al9
with permission from Update Software. |
|
In summary, prednisolone, IVIg and PE are probably equally effective
in the short term, and have not been compared in the long
term, so the choice depends mainly on cost, adverse
effects, and personal preference. We usually recommend
starting treatment with oral prednisolone in patients for
whom there are no contraindications (obesity,
hypertension, diabetes, ulcer history). If it is not
effective we use IVIg, followed by PE. In pure motor CIDP we
start with IVIg. Immunosuppressive agents, initially
azathioprine, are mostly used in patients who have failed
to respond to the above treatments. Their effects have
probably not been fairly tested, as these patients often
have significant axonal degeneration..
Azathioprine is a broad spectrum immunosuppressive agent and
may have a steroid sparing action. Several small case series
suggested improvement with 3 mg/kg daily but the effect onset
may be delayed by 3–12 months (level 3 evidence). The
only randomised trial showed no major effect at 2 mg/kg for
nine months, but was underpowered. Side effects include
nausea, diarrhoea, rash, leucopenia, altered liver
function (requiring long term blood monitoring),
infection, and a theoretical risk of neoplasia.
Azathioprine is metabolised by thiopurine methyl
transferase and 10% of the population are heterozygotes and
0.3% homozygotes for its deficiency. Measurement of enzyme
values identifies the heterozygotes, whose dose should be
halved, and homozygotes, who should probably not be given
the drug. It should not be used with allopurinol.
Cyclophosphamide is an alkylating agent, which predominantly
depletes B lymphocytes. Intravenous cyclophosphamide in pulses
of 1 g/m2
monthly for up to six months induced notable improvement
in 12 of 15 patients in one series. It is probably effective
(level 3 evidence) but risks serious side effects on the
bladder, marrow, and gonads. Oral cyclophosphamide 2
mg/kg is a simpler alternative with fewer short term side
effects.
Cyclosporin A particularly inhibits T lymphocyte proliferation.
In the largest series, all 14 patients improved either in
disability or in relapse rate (level 3 evidence). Over
half had adverse effects, including nephrotoxicity,
hypertension, nausea, oedema, and hirsutism, so lower
doses are now recommended, starting at 3–7 mg/kg daily
and maintenance at 2–3 mg/kg.
Interferons are naturally occurring cytokines. Beta interferon
1a (Rebif) down regulates inflammatory responses and was
beneficial in some small series at 44 µg subcutaneously
three times weekly for about six months. The one
randomised trial showed no benefit, but used only 22 µg
three times weekly for three months in patients resistant
to other treatments. Alpha interferon upregulates immune
responses, and has been reported occasionally to cause
CIDP and other autoimmune diseases. Nevertheless, it may
be beneficial in CIDP, and 15 of 26 patients improved
with alpha interferon 2a 2-3 MIU subcutaneously three times
weekly for six weeks. Both interferons are very expensive but
usually have only minor adverse effects.
There are a few reports of the efficacy in CIDP of methotrexate,
tacrolimus (FK506), mycophenolate, etanercept, and autologous
stem cell transplantation.
Go to page-4